Big Brother Gifts from New Baby
Bringing home a new baby is magical, but your toddler might not see it that way initially—trust me, I learned this the hard way as a mom of 5! Studies show that many older siblings feel jealousy, insecurity or displaced attention when a new baby arrives. That's where "big brother gifts from new baby" comes in—a game-changer for smoothing this major family transition.
From my own experience navigating multiple sibling adjustments, I've seen firsthand how these special presents aren't just about materialism—they're about making your older child feel valued and important during a time when everything is changing. After welcoming baby number two, three, four, and five, I discovered that a thoughtful gift can transform those initial feelings of uncertainty into genuine excitement about being a big brother.
Whether you're still working through your baby registry checklist or already dealing with newborn sleep challenges, preparing your older child with a meaningful gift is just as important as all the other preparations you're making.
This post may have affiliate links, which means I may receive commissions if you choose to purchase through links I provide (at no extra cost to you). As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Read more about these links in my disclaimer policy.
Getting Started with Big Brother Gifts Idea from New Baby
Personalized Big Brother Gifts That Become Treasured Keepsakes
Personalized gifts hit different because they're made specifically for your child—items that celebrate their new title and become keepsakes they'll treasure for years.
Custom clothing is the most popular option. Big brother t-shirts, hoodies, and pajamas with their new title make kids feel like superheroes.
Clothing options that work well:
Custom t-shirts with establishment dates - Shows the exact date they became a big brother
Hoodies with their name and "Big Bro" on the back - Makes them feel official
Matching sibling outfits - For adorable photo ops later
Pajama sets with superhero "Big Brother" themes - Helps with bedtime resistance
Order 3-4 weeks before your due date for custom orders.
Engraved jewelry works surprisingly well, even for young boys. Simple bracelets, dog tags, or keychains with their name and "Big Brother" become treasured items. A toddler might wear it briefly, then it becomes a keepsake box item they rediscover as teenagers.
Personalized storybooks are incredible if you have the budget. Companies create books specifically about becoming a big sibling, putting your child's name and sometimes their face into the story.
Picture frames serve double duty. Find frames that say "Big Brother" or have spaces for photos of both siblings. Many have three photo slots—one for the older kid, one for the baby, and one for them together.
Pro tip: Get two personalized items—a smaller item for the hospital meeting (like a t-shirt) and a more special keepsake (like a book or jewelry) for when you get home. This spreads out the excitement.
Monogrammed room décor works for older kids who understand personal space. Blankets, pillows, wall letters, or a comforter with their initials helps them feel special when everything revolves around the baby.
The key with personalized gifts: quality over quantity. One really nice item beats five cheap things that break within a week.
Practical Big Brother Gifts That Keep Toddlers Engaged
These are the MVP gifts—ones that keep your toddler busy when you're deep in diapers and cluster feeding. They might not be as sentimental, but they're lifesavers during those first exhausting weeks.
Activity books and coloring sets are seriously underrated. Get the good stuff—reusable water coloring books, sticker activity books, or mess-free markers that only work on special paper.
Top activity items:
Melissa & Doug reusable sticker pads - Hours of entertainment, zero mess
Crayola Color Wonder sets - Markers that only work on special paper, can't stain furniture
Water Wow books - Fill pen with water, "paint" pages, they dry to use again
Usborne lift-the-flap books - Interactive and engaging for toddlers/preschoolers
Scratch art rainbow papers - Scrape away black coating to reveal colors
Building sets are another winner. LEGO DUPLO sets are perfect for ages 2-4, regular LEGO for 5+. A big tub of DUPLO blocks provides endless entertainment.
Puzzles improve cognitive skills while keeping kids occupied. For 3-year-olds, stick with 24-48 piece puzzles. For 5-year-olds, go up to 100 pieces. Get multiple puzzles and rotate them to keep interest high.
Art supplies can be risky because of mess, but with a designated art station, they're fantastic. Washable everything is your friend.
Art cart essentials:
Glue sticks (liquid glue gets messy)
Play-dough in containers
The "big kid" toy strategy works incredibly well. Give your older child a toy marketed for their age or slightly older—it emphasizes they're growing up, not being replaced. A balance bike positioned as their "big kid bike because they're not a baby anymore" creates pride and ownership.
Avoid toys requiring heavy parental involvement. Don't get complicated science kits needing adult supervision for every step when you're about to have a newborn.
Experience-Based Big Brother Gifts and Special Privileges
Experience gifts and special privileges often mean more than physical presents—creating memories, granting new freedoms, and giving your older child something to look forward to.
The "Big Brother Day Out" is genius. Create a certificate or coupon promising a special one-on-one outing with mom or dad—zoo, ice cream, park, or library. The key: it's their time, with no baby involved.
For more ideas on making these outings special, explore kid-friendly Christmas party ideas.
How to make experience gifts work:
Be specific about what the experience includes - Tell them exactly what you'll do
Set a realistic timeframe - Give yourself a month or two, not "next week"
Follow through no matter what - Crucial for building trust
Take photos during the outing - Creates lasting memories
Zoo and museum passes provide multiple outings over time. An annual pass can be used all year, providing regular one-on-one time.
Special privileges cost nothing financially but mean everything emotionally. New freedoms that emphasize they're growing up:
Staying up 15 minutes later than before
Choosing what the family eats for dinner one night per week
Picking the movie for family movie night
Having special one-on-one breakfast with dad on Saturday mornings
Being allowed to use "big kid" scissors or kitchen tools with supervision
Getting to answer the doorbell when visitors arrive
Having their own special shelf in the fridge for snacks
The "helper" kit includes baby-safe items your older child can use to help with baby care—a baby doll for practice, a special step stool for reaching the changing table, or baby-safe wipes they can hand you. Sometimes the "help" slows you down, but the emotional payoff is worth it.
Subscription boxes keep giving. There are boxes for every interest: arts and crafts, science experiments, books, building toys ($20-40/month). A new box arriving each month reminds your older child they're still special. If you're looking for related gift ideas, browse our Christmas gift ideas for kids for more inspiration.
Experience gifts create anticipation and ongoing connection. Physical toys get forgotten, but experiences and privileges woven into daily life shape your relationship and help your older child feel secure.
Books About Becoming a Big Brother
Books serve multiple purposes—entertainment, education, and emotional processing all rolled into one.
"I'm a Big Brother" by Joanna Cole is the classic. Simple, straightforward, perfect for ages 2-3. It walks through what having a baby sibling means without sugarcoating—babies cry, sleep a lot, need diaper changes.
"The New Baby" by Mercer Mayer featuring Little Critter is excellent, especially for kids who already love these books. Little Critter goes through genuine feelings—excitement, annoyance, love—helping kids feel less alone.
"Big Brother Daniel Tiger" is perfect if your kid loves the show. Uses familiar characters and songs to teach about becoming a big sibling. Great for ages 2-4 (around $5, board book format).
Interactive books with flaps, textures, and moving parts work great for kids with shorter attention spans. The physical interaction gives fidgety kids something to do while you read ($10-15).
Other worthwhile books:
"What to Expect When the New Baby Comes Home" - Sets realistic expectations with real family photos
"Waiting for Baby" by Rachel Fuller - Great for kids still waiting for baby's arrival
"Za-Za's Baby Brother" by Lucy Cousins - Simple story with bold, colorful illustrations
"Big Brothers Are the Best" by Fran Manushkin - Celebrates positive aspects of being an older sibling
Custom books where your child becomes the actual character are really engaging. Companies like Wonderbly create personalized books with your child's name, appearance, and sometimes family structure ($25-35).
Start with 2-3 books about 6-8 weeks before your due date. Read them regularly so your child becomes familiar with concepts. Include one special new book as part of the big brother gift from the baby.
Use books as conversation starters. After reading a page about babies crying or needing attention, pause and ask your child how they feel about that.
Budget-Friendly Big Brother Gift Ideas Under $25
You don't need to spend a lot for it to be meaningful and effective.
Dollar stores and Five Below are excellent for toys, activity books, puzzles, and craft supplies for $1-5 each. For more budget-conscious inspiration, see our budget Christmas gifts for toddlers guide.
Dollar store finds:
Coloring books and crayon sets
Play-dough containers in multiple colors
Small toy cars or figurines
The trick: presentation. Put together a "big brother activity basket" with several small items, wrap it nicely, and present it with excitement.
DIY gifts can be super creative while spending almost nothing. Homemade gifts often become more treasured because of the personal touch. You can find more creative options in our DIY Christmas gift ideas or homemade Christmas gifts under $20 guides.
Homemade coupon books are favorites. Create little coupons your child can "cash in" for special privileges or activities using just construction paper, markers, and scissors.
Coupon book ideas:
Stay up 30 minutes late
Choose a special movie night
Ice cream date with mom or dad
Park playdate, just you and me
Build a blanket fort together
Pancakes for dinner
Extra bedtime story
Choose the music in the car all day
Skip one chore (age-appropriate)
Baking cookies together
Painted picture frames from thrift stores work great. Grab a simple frame for $1-2, then decorate it together with paint, stickers, or markers. The activity becomes quality one-on-one time, and the finished product becomes a keepsake. For more crafting fun, try these Christmas crafts for preschoolers or holiday crafts that are toddler-friendly.
Second-hand stores, thrift shops, and Facebook Marketplace are goldmines. Find gently used toys, books, puzzles, and games for a fraction of retail cost. Kids don't care if something is new—they only care if it's new to them.
Digital gifts like movie downloads, app subscriptions, or game passes cost little and provide entertainment value. Download a few new educational apps or games as the "gift."
Simple certificates printed at home can feel special with the right presentation. Use free templates online or make your own. Put it in a dollar store frame for display.
Kids respond to your energy and excitement more than the price tag. Present a $5 item with genuine enthusiasm, and they'll receive it that way.
Luxury and Premium Big Brother Gifts for Milestone Moments
If you have the budget, premium gift options can mark this milestone in a truly special way—creating something with lasting value.
High-end toys from brands like Melissa & Doug, Hape, or Plan Toys are built to last through multiple kids and often become family heirlooms. Solid wood construction, beautiful design, toys that don't break after a week ($50-200).
Premium building sets like LEGO Architecture, Magna-Tiles, or Tegu magnetic blocks are both fun and educational. A 100-piece Magna-Tile set ($50-100) provides years of entertainment.
Custom jewelry from specialty jewelers becomes a true keepsake. Real sterling silver or gold pieces with professional engraving are heirloom quality ($75-200).
Professional photoshoots create lasting memories. Photographers capture those early sibling moments ($200-500 for a session). For tips on capturing these moments yourself, check out our Christmas family photo ideas.
What to look for in a photographer:
Experience working with young children
Portfolio showing natural, candid moments
Patience and flexibility with kids
Willingness to work in your home
Editing style you love
Package including digital files
Personalized nursery art and custom illustrations celebrate your children. Commission artists to create custom prints featuring both kids' names, special quotes, or illustrated portraits.
Experience packages like theme park trips or special vacations create lasting memories ($500-5000+). If you were planning a vacation anyway, reframing it as celebrating becoming a big brother adds emotional significance.
The key with luxury gifts: make them thoughtful and personal, not just expensive. Ensure they align with your child's interests or create lasting memories.
Age-Appropriate Gift Selection Guide
Picking the right gift depends on your older child's age and developmental stage.
Best Gifts for Toddlers (18 months - 3 years)
This age needs sensory engagement and can be used independently without much setup. Board books with textures, large building blocks, push toys, or musical instruments work great.
What worked well:
Mega Blocks in a big container ($25-35) - Large blocks, safe and easy to manipulate
Musical instruments like drums or xylophones ($15-25) - Noisy but engaging
Pop-it or fidget toys ($5-10) - Satisfying sensory feedback
Bath toys ($10-20) - Makes bath time fun entertainment
Simple shape sorters or stacking toys ($10-15) - Developmental and engaging
Toddlers respond well to anything that lights up or makes noise. These toys captivate this age group and provide 30-45 minutes of entertainment. For more age-specific ideas, see our guides on gifts for 2-year-olds and gifts for 3-year-old boys and girls.
Safety is crucial. Avoid anything with small parts (choking hazards), button batteries, small removable pieces, or sharp edges.
Ideal Presents for Preschoolers (3-5 years)
This is the sweet spot—old enough to understand what's happening but young enough to be excited about presents. Longer attention spans, can handle more complex toys, developing real interests.
Preschoolers love anything that makes them feel grown-up and capable. They want to be helpers, developing independence, understanding their place in family structure.
Preschool-friendly gift ideas:
Dress-up costumes - Encourages imaginative play
Play kitchen or tool bench - Dramatic play that occupies them
Beginner board games - Simple games like Candy Land or Chutes and Ladders
Ride-on toys or scooters - Physical activity outlet
Science kits for young kids - Simple experiments that feel "big kid"
Preschoolers are developing social awareness and starting to compare and notice fairness. If the baby gets gifts from visitors and they don't, they'll notice.
For related sibling gift ideas, you might also like our big sister Christmas gifts and gifts for toddlers from new baby articles.
Thoughtful Options for School-Age Brothers (6+ years)
Once kids hit elementary age, needs and interests shift dramatically. They're more aware, have established hobbies, and don't need as much entertainment.
School-age kids often hide feelings about the new baby because they think they should be mature. Gifts should acknowledge both their maturity and continued importance.
Experience gifts really shine at this age. Taking them to a concert, sporting event, or special outing creates memories and quality time.
Gift ideas for school-age kids:
Sports equipment for their favorite activity - Soccer ball, basketball, skateboard
Book series or graphic novels - Percy Jackson, Dog Man, whatever they're into
Craft or hobby kits matching their interests - Jewelry making, model building, painting
Age-appropriate video games - If your family does gaming
Music player or headphones - Their own device for independence
Room décor they choose - Letting them redecorate emphasizes their space
School-age kids appreciate being consulted and involved. Instead of just giving a gift, give them a budget and let them choose. You might also consider non-toy Christmas gifts for kids that focus on experiences rather than physical items.
Considerations for Large Age Gaps
When there's a big age difference (5+ years), the older child might not be interested in typical "big brother" stuff. A 10-year-old won't wear a "Big Brother" t-shirt to school.
Focus on gifts acknowledging their maturity and unique relationship with the baby—a journal for recording thoughts, special jewelry they'll actually wear, or a savings bond. While you're thinking about the whole family, don't forget to check out Christmas gifts for new dad, gifts for husband from wife and baby, and holiday gift guide for new moms.
Safety Considerations
Always check age recommendations and follow them. Those recommendations exist for developmental appropriateness and safety testing.
Biggest safety concerns:
Choking hazards (anything smaller than a toilet paper tube for kids under 3)
Button batteries (extremely dangerous if swallowed)
Long cords or strings (strangulation risk)
Small magnets (can cause serious internal damage if swallowed)
Toxic materials or lead paint
Since your older child will be around a newborn, be extra cautious about small parts. Create a designated area for toys with small pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I give the big brother gift from the new baby?
Give it when your older child first meets the baby—at the hospital or when arriving home. This creates an immediate positive association.
How much should I spend on a big brother gift?
Anywhere from $10-100+ depending on your budget. The emotional significance matters more than price—even a $5 gift presented with love makes a huge impact.
Should the gift come from the baby or from the parents?
Present it as coming "from the baby." This helps your older child associate the new sibling with something positive right from the start.
What if my older child doesn't seem interested in the gift?
This is completely normal. They may be overwhelmed or processing big emotions. Don't push—keep the gift accessible and let them engage in their own time.
Do I need to get gifts for the big brother from every visitor who brings baby gifts?
No. However, keeping a small stash of inexpensive items ($1-3) on hand for particularly hard moments can help. You can also ask close family to bring something small for the older sibling.
How can I make homemade big brother gifts feel special?
Wrap it nicely, add personalization with their name or details, include a meaningful card "from the baby," and present it with genuine enthusiasm. Handmade gifts carry love that store-bought items can't match.
Final Thoughts
Welcoming a new baby is a major transition. Big brother gifts aren't about buying affection—they honor your child's important new role and create positive associations from that first meeting.
Choose something fitting your child's personality and your family's values. Don't let social media pressure you. Some days will be hard, but your family will find its rhythm.
The gift symbolizes that expanding your family doesn't diminish your love—it expands it. Your older child doesn't need perfection; they need presence, patience, and reassurance that your love hasn't changed. Permit yourself to do this imperfectly. Welcome to the beautiful adventure of multiple kids.
